We warned readers last
month about Timeless Software's excessive valuation ahead of its listing
on GEM. Now in a new year's eve announcement we see that it has spent 40%
of its IPO proceeds on a luxury 79th floor office in Central, a
spectacular office at a spectacular price. This company is morphing into a
property investor. We'll tell you what we think it is really worth... |
Timeless Property
31st December 1999
Traditionally the period during major holidays, such as the
3-day week between Christmas and New Year, is the time for companies to get
their worst results out and slip in a few dodgy transactions before the
year-end. This year was no different. The theory is that yesterday's news gets
thrown away with the newspapers and by the time you return from your holidays
you won't hear about it.
So it comes as no surprise that the last trading day of the
millennium sees the first listed "technology" company on GEM spend 40%
of its listing proceeds on.... property. As the company had minimal net assets
before the IPO, the consideration also amounts to 37% of Timeless' post-IPO net
assets.
In yesterday's
announcement
(PDF format), Timeless Software said that it is buying the
79th floor of "The Center" at 99 Queen's Road, from major developer
Cheung Kong (Holdings). This brand new building is actually nearer Sheung Wan
than Central but we won't quibble - whoops, we just did.
The price is HK$178,375,500 for a gross floor area of 13,213 sq
ft. That works out at exactly $13,500 per sq ft. The
Center is one of the tallest buildings in Hong Kong and the views from the
79th floor will be spectacular, but so is the price. Most software systems
companies are content to rent decent offices with good communications in areas
like Kwun Tong or Quarry
Bay at around $10-15 per sq ft per month.
They could buy that space for about $4,000 psf. Even floors in
the Lippo Centre in Admiralty, with sea view, would probably only fetch about
$8,000 psf. So Timeless is paying top dollar for top-floor office space - and
the lease on its old office in China Resources Building still has a year to run.
This company is becoming less of a software services company and more of a
property speculator.
Completion is scheduled for 31-Mar-00 but Timeless can extend
this to 30-Jun-00 if interest is paid at Prime rate. 30% was payable in cash up
front, 20% is payable by completion date "by cash or such other form or
manner as may be mutually agreed" and 50% in cash on completion.
The wording of the second instalment here is a reference to the
GEM Rule against issuing any new shares for 6 months following the listing date
(25-Nov-99) which would take them up to 25-May-00. But don't get excited, even
if the 20% was satisfied in Timeless shares at current levels, this would only
amount to about 1% of the issued share capital of Timeless. So this would
not be a strategic stake for Cheung Kong. For them, this is just a handy way to
book some more profit before the 31-Dec year end.
Weak justification
The announcement states that the transaction "allows
the company to strengthen its business relationship with Cheung Kong with
opportunities to provide IT and internet related services" but the
agreement does not, as far as we know, relate to any such thing. Um right... so
if we buy a washing machine from Fortress (owned by Hutchison), does that
strengthen our business relationship with them with a view to providing
financial commentary?
The purchase price represents 40% of the IPO proceeds. In the
"use of proceeds" section of the prospectus, $250m was allocated to
specific purposes (including $100m for acquisitions) and the balance of $200m
was for "working capital". Fixed assets such as office property are
hardly working capital, and we think this amounts to a change in use of
proceeds, just one month after the IPO, which was sponsored by ING
Barings.
In an article last month Webb-site.com
warned readers before the IPO about the inflated valuation on Timeless, which is
just a software systems integrator. After reaching $7.70 on the first day of
trading, the shares fell to $3.575 on 29-Dec-99 before rebounding 26% yesterday
to $4.50. That leaves the company valued at $3.38bn, or 121 times Mar-00
forecast earnings (weighted average) or 167 times fully-diluted earnings, or 78
times last year's turnover (44% of which came from Y2K work, what you might call
a sunset industry). Moreover, at 7 times net asset value it is about 10 times
over-valued as a property investment vehicle.
So take your pick - is it a software systems integrator or a
property investor? Either way this stock cannot be worth more than $0.50-0.70
on fundamentals.
© Webb-site.com, 1999
Sign up for our free newsletter
Recommend Webb-site.com to a friend
Important notice: All material on this site, except
where otherwise accredited, is copyright to Webb-site.com.
Media and researchers are welcome to quote from articles on this site, provided that such
quotation is attributed to Webb-site.com. The
information in this site should not be relied upon by any person in making any investment
decision. No responsibility or liability is accepted by Webb-site.com or any person
related to it for any loss arising from or in reliance upon the whole or any part of the
contents of this site. Persons who are in any doubt about an investment or potential
investment should take professional investment advice. From time to time parties associated with Webb-site.com may
own long or short positions in securities issued by or related to companies or governments
on which we comment.
Back to top
|