Webb-site Reports
News, analysis and opinions since 1998

Search organisations
Search people
Search the site
Get our free newsletter!
Sign the petition for C Y Leung to send a new report to the NPCSC

Our stories

Yes Pope Frank, we can mock faiths
Pope Francis says its OK to punch someone who insults his mother, and we cannot make fun of faith. No, it's not. No insult justifies an assault, whether it's an insult against you, your mother or Muhammad, and whether it is a punch, a massacre or a state-sponsored flogging. Laws against blasphemy, insult and mockery have no place in an open society and incentivise intolerance of free speech. (17-Jan-2015)

Occupy school suspension order was invalid
We have investigated the Government's actions during the "Occupy" protests and find that it lacked the legal powers to order district-wide class suspensions, and was therefore acting outside the rule of law. (13-Jan-2015)

The bubbles in CNN
We warn investors of 3 bubbles amounting to HK$20.0bn (US$2.58bn) in the "Chung Nam Network" of listed companies, Heritage (0412), Rising Dev (1004) and Mascotte (0136) and look at a blatantly bad decision by the board of Hao Tian (0474), and an undisclosed Very Substantial Acquisition by that company. One of the bubbles is even a Russian doll "double bubble" - one owns the other. (8-Jan-2015)

Imperial Pacific bubble
We look at the HK$24.8bn (US$3.2bn) bubble in Imperial Pacific (1076) surrounding a Macau junket operation and a casino project in Saipan. (8-Jan-2015)

Petition filed with SEHK and Listing Committee
We close and submit the petition on 1-share-1-vote, and call on the Listing Committee to get back to improving the quality of HK's market rather than trying to degrade it, starting with 4 key issues. (2-Jan-2015)

Kuangchi the stratospheric stock
Our latest New Year bubble worth popping is Kuangchi (0439), HK's top-performing stock of 2014, valued at HK$32.03bn (US$4.13bn) or 16.1x NTAV. (2-Jan-2015)

SFC actions risk chilling critics
A New Year's Eve SFAT ruling reveals an SFC action against Moody's for its 2011 "red flags" report, following the recent launch of MMT action against a short-selling analyst. The SFC risks chilling publication of critical opinion and analysis - something we would hate to stop doing. We will be watching the cases carefully. (1-Jan-2015)

Where will it end?
The judge in the Hui-Kwok trial resorted to quoting Sir Humphrey Appleby in rejecting Bloomberg's request for a copy of fund flow charts presented to the jury. (31-Dec-2014)

Government changes Basic Law facts
In a Webb-site exclusive, we reveal that the HK Government has revised its own fact sheets on the Basic Law with politically-sensitive consequences. (18-Dec-2014)

Moving on from Occupy to the Central Issue
The protesters have overstayed their welcome in Admiralty. They should withdraw and set a new deadline for C Y Leung to do the right thing: send a new report to the NPCSC, recommending restoring the nomination threshold to 12.5% from 50%. That would achieve free and fair elections without civic nomination. After all, only 305 members of the 1200-member committee nominated him in 2012. A New Year's Day march should celebrate or protest his choice. Sign the petition! (7-Dec-2014)

The right to remember: keeping public data public
The slides from a speech by Webb-site founder David Webb to the AGM of the Hong Kong Library Assocation tonight. (5-Dec-2014)

Freedom of Speech v Privacy - can public domain information be private?
These are the slides of a presentation by Webb-site founder David Webb to a Year 12 (Form 6) school class today. (25-Nov-2014)

Other news

HKICPA fines Louis Tang Wai Hung, Chow Chi Kit & W.H. Tang & Partners CPA Ltd
HKICPA, 30-Dec-2015
This concerns Celebrate (8212), an acquisition circular and its annual audit for 30-Jun-2010. This is the 2nd sanction in a year against Mr Tang and his firm. The panel calls them "serious breaches" and fines them HK$50k each. Seriously? Another reason why the HKICPA should stop self-regulating. Celebrate paid the firm audit fees of HK$2.7m that year, so the fine is trivial. A ban on practising for a prolonged period would be more meaningful.

Hutchison (Three) negotiating to buy O2
Company announcement, 23-Jan-2015
We'll be impressed if they can get that past UK and EU competition regulators. It would reduce UK consumer choice to three major mobile spectrum-holders: Hutch-O2, BT-EE and Vodafone.

HKICPA bans Francis Lam Chi Ming and Lee Ho Yee for 2 years, reprimands KL CPA Ltd. Webb-site Total Return
HKICPA, 22-Jan-2015
This concerns the 31-Mar-2010 audit of Code Agriculture (8153), which has so far been the only HK-listed audit client of the firm. We warned investors about that company on 25-May-2010. The stock has returned -82.19% since then. Mr Lam is also the company secretary of China Aluminium Cans (6898).

HKSAR v Shirlina Tsang Pui Yu: costs
HK Court of Appeal, 22-Jan-2015
Shirlina Tsang, who defrauded RBS by cooking her trading books, gets half her appeal costs having succeeded on one of two grounds of appeal to reduce her sentence from 50 months to 46 months.

HKSAR v Mak Chun Kong
HK Court of Appeal, 19-Jan-2015

12 charged with bribery & fraud over village house projects
ICAC, 14-Jan-2015
Ding ding! David Li Yam Pui, the 81-year-old developer, allegedly conspired with the Chairman of the Sha Tin Rural Committee, who has not been charged, to offer him not more than HK$200k for "introducing" each indigenous male for a small-house licence application. In case you are wondering, he is Mok Kam Kwai, BBS. As Chairman of the SRC he is a Heung Yee Kuk Councillor and ex officio Sha Tin District Councillor.

Enerchina (0622) buys 1.5bn shares (5.58%) of Mascotte (0136) for HK$210m
Disclosure of interest, 14-Jan-2015
This is an off-market transaction and increases its stake to 9.51%. The 5-day average market cap of Enerchina before the purchase was $1432m, so the "consideration ratio" is 14.7% and this should be a Disclosable Transaction under the Listing Rules. Enerchina has not made any announcement. In our view, Enerchina has just bought into the Mascotte bubble.

CKH-HWL mega-shakeup. Company registration
Company announcement, 9-Jan-2015
So now we know why CK Hutchison Holdings Ltd (Cayman) was registered in HK on New Year's Eve. We saw it, but didn't know what it was for.

Ageas Insurance Co (Asia) Ltd v Inneo Lam Hau Wah
HK Court of Appeal, 9-Jan-2015
Inneo Lam loses his appeal. He rose to fame in the PCCW privatisation vote-rigging case of 2009.

Previously on Webb-site.com
Check out our full list of articles in the archive, since our launch in 1998.

Sign up for our free newsletter

Click to recommend Webb-site.com to a friend

Important notice: All material on this site, except where otherwise accredited, is copyright to Webb-site.com. Media are welcome to quote from articles on this site, provided that such quotation is attributed to Webb-site.com. The information in this site should not be relied upon by any person in making any investment decision. No responsibility or liability is accepted by Webb-site.com or any person related to it for any loss arising from or in reliance upon the whole or any part of the contents of this site. Persons who are in any doubt about an investment or potential investment in a security should take professional advice before making their decisions in relation to any investment. From time to time parties associated with Webb-site.com may own long or short positions in securities issued by or related to companies or governments on which we comment.

Back to top

RSS feed Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Facebook YouTube channel

Get Firefox Due to a bug in Internet Explorer 7 and earlier, menus on this site do not function properly in those browsers. Charts on this site don't work in IE8 or earlier. IE9 is good but only available for Windows Vista or later. Firefox works fine.

Today's birthdays, 25 January
From Webb-site Who's Who
de Beauchamp, Richard 633
Cavendish, William (1641) 374
Thynne, Thomas (1765) 250
Kidston, George Jardine (1873) 142
de Rothschild, Lionel Nathan (1882) 133
Lim, Mary Siew Tong 129
Law, Pey Fong 112
Fok Lui, Yin Nei 89
Chow Liang, Selina Shuk Yee 70
Ng, Margaret Ngoi Yee 67
Gan, Song Chun 57
Freud, Emma Vallencey 53
Lee, Patrick Kin Lond 50
Wong, Pindar Pin Dar 46

Today's air pollution
Hedley Index

Central (Victoria Harbour)